Thursday, May 28, 2009

If a book doesn't catch my attention immediately I tend to put it down and then forget why I picked it up in the first place. That's why I always have several going at the same time.
For example, I picked up The Senator's Wife in Target before we left for Fla.
I knew I had wanted to to read it because I read about it in Entertainment Weekly. But I can't remember more than that, so I trusted my instinct and picked it up.
In Florida, I read the first chapter. I just didn't get back to reading. I napped a lot, though. It was vacation, after all.
It has been a few weeks now and I have found myself thinking about it so I plan to pick i tup again soon.

When we got home, my Amazon order had arrived and I started reading the Dr. Laura book I had been waiting for. I am not a Dr. Laura listener or fan. I have never read a book by her but I don't live under a rock, I knew who she was. And the title was worth taking a look at. So, I began to read. I felt connected right away. I love this book so much and highly, HIGHLY recommend it for all stay-at-home mothers.

I have to caveat here, if you are a working mother - regardless of why - do not pick this book up.
It is very, VERY hard to stomach the VERY one-sided-ness of Dr. Laura.
She firmly and without give, believes that a mother should be home, caring for her children, home and husband. And I have yet to see her yield for any reason other than death of the husband. She does say, though, that daycare is better for children of drug-addicts or whores. Nice of her, eh?

So - I have to say that while I find it hard to see around her sometimes, I also find myself agreeing with her far more than I thought I ever would.

Frankly - I, too, believe that mothers belong at home. I really, really wish that every mommy in the world could stay home and love, nurture, protect and provide from the safe, cozy place of home. It is a dream of mine to always be here. I want to be here now, as my babies are new to the world and everything it offers. And I want to be here later, when they come off the bus with all the stress and fears, pride and excitement of the school ages.

So, that part of Dr. Laura's opinion is very difficult. She sees no reason why a woman, once becoming a mother, would do anything but be home.

There isn't any easy way to have that discussion.
It always ends up as "Working Mom vs Stay-at-Home Mom" and I hate that. It's not a good discussion because it doesn't go anywhere. It goes around and around and around, there is no one way, no answer, no solution, no finality.
Being the best mom you can be, the best way you can, the way that makes you happy and your family happy - that is the right way. Not the way that Dr. Laura says you should.

The last book I am reading right now is Columbine by Dave Cullen. I haven't read past what you can see on Amazon yet. I plan to pick it up after I put Dr. Laura down and finish the Senator. I remember that tragic day so well. I was young, it made a huge impact on me as a person. I seriously didn't read or watch the news for years after that. Years. I'm not kidding.

But, I am borrowing Twilight from Carly tonight, so if that is as quick a read as I hear it is, I will read that first. It is the book for June's Book Club (fun, light, summer read!) so I need to read it by June 15 if I'm gonna read it for that meeting.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Golly...You almost sound like you feel guilty that you are a stay at home mom. Its the second time you brought this topic up. what up wit dat?

Kim said...

Shoot...I just had a comment typed out and I lost my wireless. Damnit...

Anyway...

I'm the same way, Liz. I have two books going right now, and they couldn't be more different from each other. Just depends which one I'm in the mood for.

Not a fan of Dr. Laura, or anyone, really, who's so one-sided and intolerant of other people's views. Going back to work is such a personal decision, one that people make for a whole host of reasons. Who am I to judge someone's reasons or decision, especially when I don't know their circumstances?

You'll have to let me know how the Columbine book is. Not sure I could bring myself to read it.

So, are you in love with Edward yet???

Unknown said...

I am a stay-at-home mom, Anonymous. It's what I do - it's bound to come up more than once on my personal blog.
Perhaps you would like to share what you do? Or...... ummmmm, I don't know - your name?

Kimmie - haven't gotten the book yet. But, ironically, I AM in love with my brother, Edward, these days - after giving me that beautiful new niece!
Full story coming soon!

Gini said...

I have been on the same friggin book, for what seems to be, forever. I have been a very poor reader lately. I really enjoy it, when I do get "into" it, because I could just read and read and read. And I love the feeling of finishing a good book. Satisfaction.

I too, like my sister could not even think about reading Dr. Laura. I stay at home, plain and simple, because I am fortunate enough to be able to do so. Period. I think good families raise good children regardless of a stay at home situation or not. There are so many more way to f#ck up your kids lives, that have nothing to do with parents working or not working. Such a personal, individual choice. That being said, I respect everyone's choice, no matter how different. I don't get the impression Dr Laura is as considerate.

Cilla said...

I have the Senator (weren't you part of the original plot to all read it together and discuss it online? That's why I bought it...) and have read exactly one chapter. Every now and then I think about it and plan to pick it up again but I never have.

As for Dr. Laura, I still like her and some of her ideals even though she wouldn't give me the time of day. Actually she'd probably yell at me...

Unknown said...

Yes, Cilla - I remember that... I didn't buy it until WAY after that, tho - that's how far that idea went!
And you're right about Dr. Laura - I can like some of her ideals/soapboxes without becoming a "follower". She makes a lot of good points - but not all good points.